Data breach, reported Sep 30, 2026
Midvale Indemnity data breach
Midvale Indemnity Company, in a letter sent under the American Family Insurance name, says an unauthorized third party used personal information from other sources to run its online auto insurance quote process between Jun 30 and Aug 20, 2026, and may have obtained driver's license numbers. Oregon and Texas list 38,381 people for Midvale, and Indiana lists 52,798 for Midvale Indemnity and American Family Connect Insurance Company. Letters offer 12 months of Cyberscout credit monitoring.
Key facts
What happened
The notice letter, dated Sep 30, 2026 and sent under the American Family Insurance name, says Midvale Indemnity Company became aware of a technical issue at the end of its online auto insurance quoting process. It says that between Jun 30, 2026 and Aug 20, 2026, an unauthorized third party used personal information obtained from other sources to generate auto insurance quotes and, as part of that, may have acquired driver's license numbers.
Midvale says it determined on or about Aug 31, 2026 which people were affected. According to the letter, none of Midvale's internal systems or databases were accessed, no policy information of current or former customers was affected, and the technical issue has been resolved. Midvale says it strengthened security controls on its quoting platforms.
What information was exposed
The letter says your driver's license number may have been affected. The Texas filing lists name and driver's license number. Because the third party started with information it already had from other sources, a person can receive this letter without ever having asked Midvale for a quote.
Who was notified
Midvale filed with Oregon and Indiana on Sep 30, 2026 and with Texas on Oct 2. A copy of the consumer letter is on file with the South Carolina Department of Consumer Affairs. Texas lists the company as an insurer based in Wisconsin.
- Oregon and Texas: 38,381 people in total, filed under Midvale Indemnity Company.
- Indiana: 52,798 people in total, filed under Midvale Indemnity and American Family Connect Insurance Company. The Indiana filing names both companies.
- Texas: 3,416 residents. Indiana: 477.
What Midvale is offering
The letter offers single bureau credit monitoring, credit report and credit score services through Cyberscout, a TransUnion company, at no charge, with alerts for 12 months from enrollment, plus fraud assistance. You must enroll at bfs.cyberscout.com/activate with the code in your letter within 90 days of the letter date. The help line, 1-833-516-8757, is open 8 a.m. to 8 p.m. Eastern, Monday to Friday, for 90 days from the letter date.
What to do now
A driver's license number can be used for fake IDs, insurance fraud and some account openings:
- If someone uses your driver's license or state ID number, report it to your state motor vehicle agency and ask whether you can get a new number.
- Check with your auto insurer that no policy or quote you did not request is tied to your name.
- Place a free credit freeze with Equifax, Experian and TransUnion. A freeze blocks new credit in your name until you lift it, and it does not affect your credit score.
- Get your free credit reports at annualcreditreport.com and look for accounts or inquiries you do not recognize. If you find identity theft, report it at IdentityTheft.gov, the Federal Trade Commission site.
- Be careful with calls, texts and emails that mention this breach or ask you to confirm personal details. Use only the phone number printed in your letter.
Lawsuits and settlements
No settlement has been announced for the Midvale Indemnity data breach as of Nov 16, 2026, in the sources Claim reviewed. A breach notice by itself does not mean a company has agreed to pay anyone.
Claim tracks new data breach settlements. If a settlement opens for this incident, Claim will list it with the claim deadline, and members can get an alert.
Frequently asked questions
Is the Midvale Indemnity letter real?
A copy of the letter, dated Sep 30, 2026 and signed by Midvale's privacy director, is on file with the South Carolina Department of Consumer Affairs, and Midvale reported the breach to Oregon, Texas and Indiana. It gives 1-833-516-8757 for questions and does not ask for payment.
Why did I get a letter if I never got a quote?
Midvale says the third party used personal information it got from other sources to request quotes. Your information could have been used that way even if you never contacted Midvale.
Will there be a Midvale Indemnity settlement?
No settlement had been announced as of Nov 16, 2026, in the sources Claim reviewed. If a lawsuit over this breach settles, people who received a notice letter are usually the ones who can file a claim. Claim tracks new settlements and can alert you if one opens.
What should I do if my Social Security number was exposed?
Midvale's letter lists only driver's license numbers. If any notice says your Social Security number was exposed, place a free credit freeze with Equifax, Experian and TransUnion, ask the IRS for an Identity Protection PIN and check your credit reports.
Claim finds settlements you qualify for and helps you file.
Get alerts if a settlement opens