Get started

Arbitration claims, related lawsuit filed Mar 12, 2026

Ace Hardware website tracking lawsuit

A March 2026 lawsuit says AceHardware.com kept sending visitors' searches and activity to Google Analytics and a Bazaarvoice pixel even after they clicked to reject optional cookies. On Nov 9, 2026 a federal judge sent those claims to arbitration under Ace's terms of use, and Levi & Korsinsky is now signing up AceHardware.com users, saying they may be entitled to up to $1,000. No claim has been decided.

Key facts

Potential payout
Up to $1,000, per Levi & Korsinsky's sign up page
Status
Sign ups open; the related court case was sent to arbitration on Nov 9, 2026
Filed
Mar 12, 2026 (related court case)
Case number
Related case: 5:26-cv-02151
Court
Related case: U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California
Who qualifies
Adults who visited AceHardware.com, created an account there or bought through the site
How to join
Levi & Korsinsky's free sign up form, or see the case on Claim

What the lawsuit says

On Mar 12, 2026, three AceHardware.com visitors from California, Indiana and Colorado filed Pflaumer v. Ace Hardware Corporation in federal court in San Jose, represented by Janove PLLC and Levi & Korsinsky. According to PPC Land's report on the complaint, they say the site's cookie banner and Cookie Settings page promised that choosing "Necessary Cookies Only" or opting out of the sale or sharing of data would stop tracking, but it did not.

The complaint says Google Analytics and the Bazaarvoice BV Pixel kept collecting data after visitors declined optional cookies. In one test, a search for "power tools" was sent to Google after the user had rejected non-essential cookies. The complaint says search terms, email addresses and purchase values can be passed this way.

The legal claims include the federal Wiretap Act, the California Invasion of Privacy Act (including its pen register section, 638.51), California consumer protection laws, invasion of privacy and unjust enrichment. Ace Hardware has not been found liable.

Who qualifies

Levi & Korsinsky's sign up page says you may qualify if you visited AceHardware.com, created an account or made a purchase through the website. The form asks you to confirm you are 18 or older. It does not list a state limit or a date range.

Follow up questions ask whether you bought anything on the site, whether you are an Ace Rewards member, when you last visited, how you used the site, and what you usually do with cookie notices (for example, rejecting them or accepting only functional cookies).

How much you could get and why

Levi & Korsinsky's page says people who used AceHardware.com may be entitled to up to $1,000. The page does not say which law that figure comes from; it refers to state and federal privacy laws in general.

For comparison, the federal Wiretap Act (18 U.S.C. 2520) lets a court award $10,000 or $100 a day, whichever is greater, and California Penal Code 637.2 allows $5,000 per violation of the California Invasion of Privacy Act. Those are maximums a court may award, not amounts Ace has offered. Arbitration claims are decided or settled one by one, so results can differ from person to person.

How to join

Fill out Levi & Korsinsky's AceHardware.com privacy sign up form. The firm says participation is free and that it is a 100% contingency firm, paid only if you are.

You can also see this case on Claim. Claim can submit some claims for you. If you have an Ace Rewards account or online orders, keep the emails or account records that show when you used the site.

Timeline

  • Mar 12, 2026: Pflaumer v. Ace Hardware Corporation is filed in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California and assigned to Judge Edward J. Davila.
  • Nov 9, 2026: Judge Davila grants Ace's motion to compel arbitration, finding the arbitration agreement in Ace's terms of use valid and enforceable, according to Bloomberg Law.
  • Nov 2026: Levi & Korsinsky takes sign ups for individual claims.

What happens next

Because the court sent the claims to arbitration, each person's claim would be brought on its own before an arbitrator rather than as a class action in court. Levi & Korsinsky's sign ups are gathering people for those individual claims.

Ace may settle the claims as a group, settle them one by one, or contest them. If arbitrators rule for Ace, claimants would get nothing.

Frequently asked questions

Is the Ace Hardware tracking lawsuit real?

Yes. Pflaumer v. Ace Hardware Corporation was filed on Mar 12, 2026 in the Northern District of California, and on Nov 9, 2026 the judge sent the claims to arbitration. Levi & Korsinsky is taking sign ups for individual claims.

Do I need proof to join?

The sign up form asks about your visits, purchases, Ace Rewards membership and cookie habits. Account records or order emails can help show you used the site.

How much could I get?

Levi & Korsinsky says up to $1,000. Nothing has been awarded, and the amount for any person would depend on a settlement or an arbitrator's decision.

Is there a deadline?

No sign up deadline has been published. Claims under privacy laws are subject to statutes of limitations, so waiting can matter.

Does it cost anything?

Levi & Korsinsky says participation is free and it is paid only if you recover money.

Do I need a lawyer?

Yes. Arbitration claims are brought individually, so you would be represented by the firm you sign up with, such as Levi & Korsinsky.

Claim can submit some claims for you.

See this case on Claim

Related pages