Get started

Class action, filed Nov 6, 2026

American Family Insurance cookie tracking lawsuit

Stacy Penning sued American Family Mutual Insurance Company, S.I. on Nov 6, 2026 in the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Wisconsin. The complaint says amfam.com tells visitors they can reject cookies, but its tracking tools from Meta, TikTok, Google and Pinterest still collect and send their browsing data after they click Reject Cookies. It seeks damages for a proposed nationwide class and a California subclass, including statutory damages under the federal Wiretap Act.

Filed
Nov 6, 2026

Key facts

Potential payout
The complaint cites Wiretap Act statutory damages of $100 a day of violation or $10,000, whichever is greater (18 U.S.C. 2520)
Status
Pending. No class certified and no sign up form
Case number
3:26-cv-01092
Court
U.S. District Court for the Western District of Wisconsin
Class counsel
Ademi & Fruchter LLP and Levi & Korsinsky LLP (proposed)
Who qualifies
People in the US who visited amfam.com and clicked Reject Cookies or otherwise declined non-essential cookies (proposed class), with a California subclass
How to join
Nothing to file now. Class members would be notified if the case settles or a class is certified

What the lawsuit says

The case is Penning v. American Family Mutual Insurance Company, S.I., No. 3:26-cv-01092, filed in the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Wisconsin. American Family is based in Madison, Wisconsin, and runs amfam.com, where people get quotes, buy policies, pay premiums and report claims.

The complaint says the site shows a privacy banner and cookie settings that let visitors accept or reject cookies, and that tell visitors who reject that their choice will be honored. It says that promise is false: tracking tools from Meta, TikTok, Google and Pinterest load as soon as a person arrives, before they can make a choice, and keep sending data after they click Reject Cookies.

According to the complaint, the data sent includes the pages and products a person views, the links, buttons and forms they click, what they type into search fields, device and browser details, cookie identifiers that recognize them across websites, and approximate location from their IP address.

The plaintiff, a California resident, says he visited amfam.com in June and July 2026 to look at auto and home insurance quotes, clicked Reject Cookies, and was logged into Facebook at the time. A footnote says that after a demand letter sent on July 22, 2026, American Family appears to have stopped tracking from Reddit after people opted out.

These are allegations. American Family has not answered the complaint, and no court has ruled on them.

Who qualifies

The complaint proposes two groups:

  • Class: all persons in the United States who visited the website during the applicable limitations period and selected Reject Cookies on the privacy banner or otherwise declined cookies other than essential cookies.
  • California subclass: members of the class who visited the website while located in California.

American Family, its officers, directors, employees and affiliates, and the judge and the judge's family are excluded. You did not need to buy a policy to fit the proposed class; the plaintiff says he had no account. No class has been certified, and a court can change these definitions.

How much you could get and why

The complaint brings six claims: common law invasion of privacy, invasion of privacy under the California Constitution, the California Invasion of Privacy Act, the federal Wiretap Act (18 U.S.C. 2510 and following), common law fraud and misrepresentation, and unjust enrichment.

For the Wiretap Act claim, the complaint cites 18 U.S.C. 2520, which allows actual damages plus the violator's profits, or statutory damages of $100 for each day of violation or $10,000, whichever is greater. For the California subclass, it cites the statutory penalties in California Penal Code 637.2. It also asks for punitive damages, restitution, interest and attorneys' fees.

These are amounts the law allows if the case wins. If the case settles, a settlement sets its own payments, which are often lower per person. No amount has been awarded or agreed.

How to join

There is no claim form and nothing to sign up for. In a class action, people who fit a certified class are usually included unless they opt out, and they are told how to claim if there is a settlement. If you rejected cookies on amfam.com, noting roughly when you visited may help later.

Timeline

  • June and July 2026: the plaintiff visits amfam.com and rejects cookies, the complaint says.
  • July 22, 2026: the plaintiff's lawyers send American Family a demand letter.
  • Nov 6, 2026: complaint filed in the Western District of Wisconsin.

What happens next

American Family has to be served and then respond, with an answer or a motion such as a motion to dismiss. The court would later decide whether to certify the proposed class or subclass. The case could also settle at any point. Nothing has been decided as of Nov 16, 2026.

Frequently asked questions

Is the American Family Insurance cookie lawsuit real?

Yes. Penning v. American Family Mutual Insurance Company, S.I., No. 3:26-cv-01092, was filed on Nov 6, 2026 in the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Wisconsin.

Do I need proof?

Nothing is needed now because there is no claim form. If a settlement opens, it may ask you to confirm that you visited amfam.com and declined cookies.

How much could I get?

The complaint cites Wiretap Act statutory damages of $100 a day or $10,000, whichever is greater, and California penalties for the subclass. A settlement, if one happens, could pay a different amount.

Is there a deadline?

No deadline applies to class members now because no class is certified and no settlement exists.

Does it cost anything?

No. Class members do not pay to be part of a class action. Lawyers in class actions are paid from any recovery if the court approves their fees.

Do I need a lawyer?

No. The plaintiff's lawyers ask to represent the proposed class. You can hire your own lawyer if you want individual advice.

Claim finds settlements you qualify for and helps you file.

Get alerts if this case settles

Related pages