
Class action, filed Nov 5, 2021
Carvana Pennsylvania delivery fee lawsuit
Pennsylvania buyers say Carvana's standard Pennsylvania retail installment contracts showed the delivery charge as N/A while listing a separate $590 transit charge, and lumped registration, title, plate and lien fees into one line. On Jan 6, 2026 Judge Mia Roberts Perez let those claims go forward under Pennsylvania's consumer protection law and dismissed the claim that buyers were charged twice. No class has been certified and no settlement has been announced.
Key facts
What the lawsuit says
In Jennings v. Carvana, LLC, consolidated with Harvin v. Carvana, LLC, buyers sue Carvana and Bridgecrest Credit Company, LLC over Carvana's standard Pennsylvania retail installment sales contract. According to the court, Dana Jennings bought a 2017 Kia Sportage in December 2020. The contract's "Delivery charge" line said "N/A," yet the total cash price was $590 more than the itemized amounts, and a separate $590 "Transit Charge" appeared in the other charges section.
The buyers also say Carvana combined registration, title, license plate and lien filing fees into one line labeled "Paid to Public Officials," hiding what each fee was. They sue under Pennsylvania's Unfair Trade Practices and Consumer Protection Law and Consumer Credit Code. Carvana has not been found liable.
Who qualifies
The amended complaint proposes a Transit Charge Class: Pennsylvania residents who signed Carvana's standard Pennsylvania contract where a delivery charge was included in the cash price but not itemized or shown as "N/A," or where a transit charge was listed separately, from six years before the Nov 7, 2024 amended complaint through class certification.
A Transit Charge Subclass covers class members whose contracts lumped registration, title, license plate and lien fees into one charge or into "Paid to Public Officials." The class is limited to Pennsylvania residents and is not certified.
How much you could get and why
No amount per person has been set. The $590 figure is the transit charge on Jennings's contract as the court described it; other buyers' charges may differ. The buyers seek damages and restitution under Pennsylvania law. Any payment would come from a judgment or a court approved settlement.
How to join
There is no sign up. If a class is certified or a settlement approved, class members would get notice. Keep your Carvana contract if you financed a car in Pennsylvania. You can see this case on Claim and follow it there.
Timeline
- Nov 5, 2021: filed in the Philadelphia Court of Common Pleas.
- Dec 9, 2021: moved to federal court.
- April 2024: the Third Circuit affirms the denial of Carvana's motion to compel arbitration.
- Jul 12, 2024: Jennings and Harvin are consolidated.
- Nov 7, 2024: amended complaint limits the class to Pennsylvania residents.
- Jan 6, 2026: the court lets the transit charge and lumped fee claims proceed and dismisses the double charge theory.
What happens next
The case continues in the district court. The plaintiffs can ask the court to certify the Pennsylvania class, and the parties may settle, as they tried in November 2024 when they agreed to a stay for settlement talks.
Frequently asked questions
Is the Carvana delivery fee lawsuit real?
Yes. Jennings v. Carvana, LLC, No. 5:21-cv-05400, consolidated with Harvin v. Carvana, LLC, No. 2:23-cv-02068, is pending in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania.
Do I need proof?
Not now. Your Carvana retail installment contract shows the delivery, transit and government fee lines, so keep it.
How much could I get?
No amount has been set. The lead buyer's contract listed a $590 transit charge.
Is there a deadline?
No. There is no claim form or claim deadline.
Does it cost anything?
No. Class members do not pay to be part of a class action.
Do I need a lawyer?
No. The named buyers' lawyers represent the proposed class.
Claim can submit some claims for you.
See this case on Claim

