
Email marketing class action, remanded to state court Nov 13, 2026
Old Navy sale emails lawsuit
Brown v. Old Navy says Old Navy sent Washington residents marketing emails with subject lines like "today only" or "three days only" for sales that kept running, which the plaintiffs say broke Washington's Commercial Electronic Mail Act (CEMA). In April 2025 the Washington Supreme Court held that CEMA bars any false or misleading information in an email subject line, and described a $500 penalty per violating email. On Nov 13, 2026 the federal court in Seattle sent the case back to state court; no class has been certified and nothing has been paid.
Key facts
What the lawsuit says
Roxann Brown and Michelle Smith sued Old Navy, LLC, Old Navy (Apparel), LLC, Old Navy Holdings, LLC, GPS Services, Inc. and The Gap, Inc. on behalf of themselves and others like them. According to the Washington Supreme Court's opinion, they say Old Navy sent emails that announced a 50 percent off promotion was ending when it kept running in the following days, and emails announcing "today only" or "three days only" promotions that were then extended.
The plaintiffs group the emails into four types: offers that lasted longer than the subject line said, old offers presented as new, offers falsely described as ending, and promotions falsely described as extended. They claim Old Navy used these subject lines to get people to open the emails and buy based on a false sense of urgency.
Washington's CEMA, RCW 19.190.020(1)(b), says no one may send a commercial email to a Washington resident that contains false or misleading information in the subject line. Old Navy has not been found liable.
Who qualifies
The case is brought for Washington residents who received Old Navy commercial emails with false or misleading subject lines. The court has not certified a class, so the exact class definition and dates are not final.
If you lived in Washington and received Old Navy sale emails with countdown or deadline subject lines, you may fit the proposed class. People in other states are not covered by this case, because CEMA protects Washington residents.
How much you could get and why
The Washington Supreme Court's April 17, 2025 opinion says CEMA sets a $500 penalty for sending Washington residents commercial emails that violate its rules (RCW 19.190.040), and that this penalty does not require a showing of actual damages. The court also said a CEMA violation is a per se violation of Washington's Consumer Protection Act.
That amount is per violating email, as the court described the law in 2025. No judgment or settlement exists, so no one has been paid. Any recovery would depend on class certification, Old Navy's pending motion to compel arbitration, and a judgment or settlement.
How to join
There is no claim form. If the state court certifies a class, Washington residents who fit the definition would be included and notified. Keep any Old Navy marketing emails you still have, since they show the subject lines you received.
Use the button on this page to get alerts from Claim if this case settles or a claim process opens.
Timeline
- May 25, 2023: The case is removed from Washington state court to the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Washington.
- April 17, 2025: The Washington Supreme Court answers the federal court's question and holds that CEMA prohibits any false or misleading information in a commercial email subject line.
- January 23, 2026: Old Navy files a motion to compel arbitration.
- May 21, 2026: The court pauses the case for mediation.
- October 29, 2026: Judge John H. Chun lifts the pause and orders the parties to show cause why the case should not be remanded for lack of federal jurisdiction.
- November 13, 2026: The court enters an order remanding the case to state court.
What happens next
Judge Chun's October 29, 2026 order said serious questions had arisen about whether plaintiffs in CEMA cases like this one have the injury in fact that federal courts require (Article III standing). The court then sent the case back to state court on November 13, 2026.
In state court, Old Navy may again ask that the claims go to individual arbitration. The case may then move toward class certification or settlement. As of November 16, 2026 there is no certified class, no settlement and no claim deadline.
Frequently asked questions
Is the Old Navy email lawsuit real?
Yes. Brown v. Old Navy, LLC was case 2:23-cv-00781-JHC in the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Washington until the court remanded it to state court on November 13, 2026. The Washington Supreme Court ruled on a question in the case on April 17, 2025.
Do I need proof?
Nothing is required now because there is no claim form. Saving Old Navy marketing emails you received can help if a settlement later asks for details.
How much could I get?
The Washington Supreme Court described a $500 penalty per violating email under RCW 19.190.040 in April 2025. Nothing has been awarded or settled.
Is there a deadline?
No claim deadline exists because there is no settlement or judgment.
Does it cost anything?
No. You do not pay or sign up to be part of a proposed class action.
Do I need a lawyer?
No. Lawyers for Roxann Brown and Michelle Smith represent the proposed class. You do not need your own lawyer to stay in a class if one is certified.
Claim finds settlements you qualify for and helps you file.
Get alerts if this case pays



