Get started

Class action, filed Oct 22, 2026

Target mac and cheese preservatives lawsuit

A class action filed on Oct 22, 2026 in federal court in New York says Target labels its Market Pantry and Good & Gather boxed macaroni and cheese as having no preservatives, while the products contain citric acid, lactic acid powder or sodium phosphate. The proposed class covers people in the U.S. who bought the products. No class has been certified and Target has not answered.

Filed
Oct 22, 2026

Key facts

Potential payout
No amount set. The complaint asks for refunds of profits, damages, and at least $50 per New York buyer under N.Y. General Business Law 349
Status
Complaint filed; no class certified; Target has not answered as of Nov 16, 2026
Case number
7:26-cv-09281
Court
U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York
Class counsel
Proposed: Reese LLP (no class counsel appointed yet)
Who qualifies
Proposed classes: people who bought the named Market Pantry or Good & Gather mac and cheese in the U.S., and a New York class, within the statute of limitations
How to join
No sign up is needed to be in a proposed class. Class members get notice if a class is certified or a settlement is approved

What the lawsuit says

On Oct 22, 2026, a Westchester County, New York shopper filed Vaughan v. Target Corporation in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York. The complaint says Target's store brand boxed macaroni and cheese is labeled "NO Artificial Flavors, Preservatives, or Synthetic Colors" or "No Artificial Preservatives," but contains citric acid, lactic acid powder or sodium phosphate, which the complaint calls known preservatives.

The complaint names eight products:

  • Market Pantry Macaroni & Cheese
  • Market Pantry Macaroni & Cheese Spirals
  • Market Pantry Deluxe Shells Macaroni & Cheese
  • Good & Gather White Cheddar Macaroni & Cheese
  • Good & Gather Shells & Aged Cheddar Macaroni and Cheese
  • Good & Gather Shells & White Cheddar Macaroni & Cheese
  • Good & Gather Elbows & Classic Cheddar Macaroni & Cheese
  • Good & Gather Macaroni & Cheese

It points to FDA rules defining a chemical preservative and to FDA material that lists citric acid as a preservative. It says shoppers pay a premium for foods without preservatives and would not have bought the products, or would have paid less, had they known. The plaintiff says she bought the products for about three years, ending around fall 2025.

The claims are deceptive practices under New York General Business Law 349, false advertising under General Business Law 350, and unjust enrichment. These are allegations. Target has not answered and no court has ruled on them.

Who qualifies

The complaint proposes two classes:

  • Nationwide class: "All persons who purchased Defendant's Products within the United States and within the applicable statute of limitation period."
  • New York class: "All persons who purchased Defendant's Products within the state of New York and within the applicable statute of limitation period."

"Products" means the eight Market Pantry and Good & Gather items listed above. Target and its affiliates, people who bought for resale, the judge and the judge's family, and people claiming personal injury are excluded. The New York law claims are brought for the New York class; the unjust enrichment claim is brought for both classes.

These are proposed definitions. A judge decides whether any class is certified.

How much you could get and why

The complaint does not name a total or a per person amount. It asks for restitution and disgorgement of Target's profits from the products, actual, statutory and punitive damages, and attorneys' fees.

For the New York class, the complaint says damages under General Business Law 349 will be no less than $50. That law lets a person recover actual damages or $50, whichever is greater. If the case settles, the amount per buyer would be set by the settlement and approved by the court.

Nothing has been awarded. Target may win the case, and buyers would then get nothing.

How to join

There is nothing to sign up for. If you bought one of the listed products you are already in the proposed class while the case is pending. If a judge certifies a class or approves a settlement, class members would get notice and, for a settlement, a claim form.

Receipts and Target Circle order history showing which products you bought can help if a settlement later asks for proof.

Claim does not list this case yet. Claim does list a separate Target case, the Target coffee creamer lawsuit. You can get alerts from Claim if this case settles.

Timeline

  • Until about fall 2025: The plaintiff buys the products for about three years, mainly Good & Gather white cheddar varieties, the complaint says.
  • Oct 22, 2026: Vaughan v. Target Corporation is filed in the Southern District of New York, case 7:26-cv-09281.
  • Nov 16, 2026: No answer from Target and no class certified.

What happens next

Target will respond to the complaint, often with a motion to dismiss. If the case continues, the parties exchange evidence and the plaintiff asks the judge to certify the classes. The case could settle at any stage, be dismissed, or go to trial.

This page will be updated when the court docket changes.

Frequently asked questions

Is the Target mac and cheese lawsuit real?

Yes. Vaughan v. Target Corporation, case 7:26-cv-09281, was filed on Oct 22, 2026 in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York.

Do I need proof to be part of it?

Not now. Nothing is being collected while the case is pending. If a settlement is approved, the claim form would say what proof, if any, is needed.

How much could I get?

No amount has been set. The complaint asks for restitution and damages, and at least $50 for New York buyers under General Business Law 349. Any payment depends on a settlement or a win.

Is there a deadline?

No. There is no settlement and no claim form, so there is no deadline yet.

Does it cost anything?

No. Class members do not pay to be in a class action. Lawyers' fees in class cases are paid from any recovery if the court approves them.

Do I need a lawyer?

No. Reese LLP filed the case for the proposed classes. You can hire your own lawyer if you want to bring your own claim.

Claim finds settlements you qualify for and helps you file.

Get alerts if this case settles

Related pages