Get started

Appeal decided, Oct 29, 2026

Ninth Circuit upholds the Blackhawk Network data breach settlement

On October 29, 2026, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit affirmed the district court's approval of the Blackhawk Network data breach class settlement in Pryor v. Blackhawk Network, Inc. The court held that the two objectors who appealed, Miriam Mabel Brown and David Lopez, are not class members and so lack standing to object. It also upheld the order requiring them to post a $15,000 appeal bond.

Key facts

Ruling
Approval of the settlement and the $15,000 appeal bond order affirmed
Appeal numbers
24-4326 and 24-6906 (district court No. 3:22-cv-07084-CRB)
Trial court
U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California (Judge Charles R. Breyer)
Decided
October 29, 2026 (submitted October 19, 2026 without oral argument)
Panel
Circuit Judges Callahan and Lee, and District Judge Ezra (sitting by designation)
Objectors
Miriam Mabel Brown and David Lopez

What the court decided

In a memorandum filed October 29, 2026, a Ninth Circuit panel of Circuit Judges Callahan and Lee and District Judge Ezra affirmed two orders of U.S. District Judge Charles R. Breyer in Pryor v. Blackhawk Network, Inc., No. 3:22-cv-07084-CRB (N.D. Cal.): the approval of the class action settlement, and the order requiring the objectors to post a $15,000 appeal bond. The panel decided the appeals, Nos. 24-4326 and 24-6906, without oral argument after they were submitted on October 19, 2026.

The memorandum is marked not for publication. Under Ninth Circuit Rule 36-3, it is not precedent for other cases, but it decides these appeals.

Why the objectors lost

The district court certified a settlement class of individuals whose personally identifiable information or payment card information was impacted in Blackhawk Network, Inc.'s data security incident. The objectors, Miriam Mabel Brown and David Lopez, said they were affected and pointed to replies from Blackhawk customer service representatives saying their cards had been impacted. The panel agreed with the district court that those statements, even if true, do not make them members of the settlement class. Because they are not class members, the panel held, they lack standing to object to the class settlement.

The objectors also argued that the settlement took away rights under California Civil Code section 1542, which limits general releases of unknown claims. The panel rejected that argument based on how the final settlement order defines the release.

On the bond, the panel held that the district court did not abuse its discretion. It noted that the objectors offered no evidence they could not pay, appear to live outside the Ninth Circuit, and were found unlikely to succeed. The memorandum adds that, as of its date, Brown and Lopez had not posted any part of the $15,000 bond. The amount came from a sworn declaration by class counsel Kiley Grombacher.

Timeline

  • November 5, 2024: Judge Breyer granted the motion for an appeal bond (Dkt. 85).
  • November 6, 2024: Ms. Brown filed a notice of appeal from the bond order (Dkt. 86), later numbered 24-6906.
  • October 19, 2026: the Ninth Circuit appeals, Nos. 24-4326 and 24-6906, were submitted without argument.
  • October 29, 2026: the Ninth Circuit filed its memorandum affirming both orders, and it was entered on the district court docket (Dkt. 88).

What it means for payments

The memorandum does not state the settlement amount or a payment date, and this article does not rely on any settlement website. Payments depend on the settlement becoming final after the appeals end, and the settlement administrator will post the payment date. As of the district court docket read on November 16, 2026, the latest entry was the October 29 memorandum.

If you filed a claim in this settlement, keep your confirmation and make sure the administrator has your current contact details. Claim does not have a page for this settlement, but it lists other open data breach settlements you may qualify for.

Frequently asked questions

Was the Blackhawk Network settlement upheld?

Yes. On October 29, 2026 the Ninth Circuit affirmed the district court's approval of the settlement in Pryor v. Blackhawk Network, Inc., appeal Nos. 24-4326 and 24-6906.

Who appealed and why did they lose?

Objectors Miriam Mabel Brown and David Lopez appealed. The court held they are not members of the settlement class and so lack standing to object to the settlement.

What was the appeal bond?

The district court required the objectors to post a $15,000 bond to cover appeal costs. The Ninth Circuit upheld that order and noted the objectors had not posted any of it.

When will Blackhawk settlement payments be sent?

The court ruling does not give a date. Payments depend on the settlement becoming final, and the settlement administrator will post the date.

Claim finds settlements you qualify for and helps you file.

Find settlements you qualify for

Related pages