Colorado Attorney General restitution, claims closed Dec 19, 2025
Four Star Realty renter refund (Colorado Attorney General)
The Colorado Attorney General is paying $980,000 of a $1 million settlement with Four Star Realty to renters who moved out of a Four Star property between Jan 1, 2020 and Dec 31, 2023 and were charged for maintenance, painting, cleaning, rekeying locks or move out coordination fees. Renters had to file a claim by Dec 19, 2025. Rust Consulting will mail checks to eligible renters.
Key facts
What happened
On Jan 9, 2024 Colorado Attorney General Phil Weiser announced a $1 million settlement with Four Star Realty, a Boulder based property management company. According to the attorney general's June 2, 2025 release, the investigation found that Four Star, which manages properties often rented by college students in Boulder, Fort Collins, Greeley and Denver, regularly charged tenants for damage they did not cause, billed them for unnecessary work, and charged fees that were not in their leases.
The settlement also requires Four Star to disclose all mandatory rent and fees, follow state utility billing law, keep photos and records of property inspections, and withhold money from a security deposit only for costs directly related to the tenant's conduct.
Who is eligible
The Four Star Realty restitution page says a tenant is eligible if they moved out of a Four Star property between Jan 1, 2020 and Dec 31, 2023 and had money wrongfully withheld from their security deposit for maintenance, painting, cleaning, rekeying locks, or unlawful move out coordination fees. The page says the date range follows the three year statute of limitations under the Colorado Consumer Protection Act.
Each eligible tenant had to file their own claim. Roommates each file separately, and no one may file for someone else. Four Star gave the attorney general records of every tenant from 2020 to 2023, and the office checks claims against those records.
How much people get
The attorney general says the entire $980,000 settlement fund will be paid on tenant claims. The final amount of each payment depends on the number and type of claims from eligible tenants, and the page says an award may be calculated based on the number of roommates a tenant had.
How and when payments arrive
The June 2, 2025 release set a Sept 2 claim deadline and said checks would begin to be mailed in November. The restitution page now gives a claim deadline of Dec 19, 2025. It says the office is reviewing claims in the order received and anticipated notifying claimants of their eligibility in March 2026. Rust Consulting, hired by the Colorado Department of Law, mails checks to eligible tenants.
How to tell the payment is real
The settlement and claims process are described on coag.gov, the Colorado Attorney General's website. The attorney general says that if it needs more information to evaluate a claim, its staff will contact the claimant directly, and that checks come from Rust Consulting. If you are unsure about a call or letter, check it against the coag.gov/fourstar page.
Who to contact
- Restitution page: coag.gov/fourstar
- To report illegal fees or withheld deposits by any landlord: StopFraudColorado.gov
Frequently asked questions
Is the Four Star Realty refund real?
Yes. The Colorado Attorney General announced the $1 million settlement on Jan 9, 2024 and runs the claims process at coag.gov/fourstar. Rust Consulting mails the checks.
Can I still file a claim?
The restitution page says claims had to be submitted by Dec 19, 2025.
What if I no longer have my move out paperwork?
The attorney general asked for as much documentation as possible, such as reconciliation statements and move out sheets, but says a claim can still be assessed without it.
Do I owe taxes on this payment?
The Colorado Attorney General pages we read do not address taxes. Ask a tax advisor about your own situation.
Claim finds settlements you qualify for and helps you file.
Find settlements you qualify for