
Appeal update, Nov 4, 2026
Real estate commission settlements: where the Eighth Circuit appeals stand
The residential real estate broker commission settlements, which the official website says total over $1 billion, have been in the Eighth Circuit on appeal. On September 1, 2026 the court affirmed in Gibson v. Mullis, No. 24-3473, and issued its mandate on October 14, 2026. On November 4, 2026 it dismissed James Mullis's later appeal, No. 26-1405, on his own stipulation. All claim deadlines have passed, and the official website gives no payment date.
Key facts
The settlements
The Residential Real Estate Broker Commissions Antitrust Settlements website says the settlements reached in this matter total over $1 billion. It groups the settling parties as follows:
- Anywhere, RE/MAX and Keller Williams
- Compass, Real Brokerage, Realty ONE, @properties, Douglas Elliman, Redfin, Engel & Völkers, HomeSmart and United Real Estate
- National Association of Realtors (NAR) and HomeServices
- Keyes, Illustrated, NextHome, John L. Scott, LoKation, Baird & Warner and Real Estate One
- Side, Seven Gables, WFP, JPAR, Signature, First Team, Sibcy Cline, Brooklyn MLS and CNYIS
- William Raveis, Howard Hanna, EXIT, Windermere, Lyon, Charles Rutenberg, My Home, Tierra Antigua and West USA
The claim deadline for the William Raveis, Howard Hanna, EXIT, Windermere, Lyon, Charles Rutenberg, My Home, Tierra Antigua and West USA settlements passed on December 30, 2025. The deadline for all earlier settlements passed on May 9, 2025.
The September 1, 2026 ruling in Gibson v. Mullis
In Gibson v. Mullis, No. 24-3473 (consolidated with Nos. 24-3478, 24-3481 and 24-3564), the appellants included James Mullis, Monty March, Robert Friedman, Benny D. Cheatham, Robert Douglass, Dena Fender and Douglas Fender. The appellees included plaintiffs Don Gibson, Lauren Criss and John Meiners and defendant brokerages, including Engel & Völkers, whose counsel argued for the defendants that joined their joint brief.
- January 14, 2026: the appeals were argued in St. Louis before Judges Lavenski R. Smith, Ralph R. Erickson and Jonathan A. Kobes.
- September 1, 2026: the court filed a published per curiam opinion, and its judgment states that the judgment of the originating court is affirmed.
- October 14, 2026: the mandate issued, which returns the case to the lower court.
On October 5, 2026, the Eighth Circuit clerk noted that the court had also issued decisions in Burnett v. Mullis (Nos. 24-2143 and 24-3619) and Burnett v. Spring Way Center (Nos. 24-2168 and 24-3444).
The later appeals, Nos. 26-1399 and 26-1405
Two later appeals, Nos. 26-1399 and 26-1405, were consolidated on April 28, 2026 and put on hold until the court decided the earlier appeals. The docket for No. 26-1405 shows:
- October 5, 2026: the stay was lifted because the earlier appeals were decided, and appellants' briefs were set for November 4, 2026.
- October 21, 2026: James Mullis asked for another stay.
- October 27, 2026: the court denied the stay and kept the November 4 brief deadline.
- November 4, 2026: Mullis filed a stipulation to dismiss No. 26-1405. The court dismissed that appeal under Federal Rule of Appellate Procedure 42(b) and issued the mandate the same day.
The entries read for this article do not show what happened to No. 26-1399 after November 4, 2026 and do not name its appellant.
What it means for you
The official website, read November 16, 2026, does not give a payment date and does not say payments have started. If you filed a claim, keep your confirmation, keep your contact details current with the administrator through the official website, and check that website for payment news. New claims cannot be filed in any of the settlements listed above.
Claim does not have a page for these settlements, but it lists other open settlements you may qualify for.
Frequently asked questions
Did the appeals court uphold the real estate commission settlements?
In Gibson v. Mullis, No. 24-3473 and three related appeals, the Eighth Circuit affirmed the judgment of the lower court on September 1, 2026 and issued its mandate on October 14, 2026.
What happened to appeal No. 26-1405?
James Mullis filed a stipulation to dismiss it on November 4, 2026, and the court dismissed it the same day under Federal Rule of Appellate Procedure 42(b).
When will Realtor commission settlement payments be sent?
The official website, read November 16, 2026, does not give a payment date.
Can I still file a claim?
No. The deadlines were May 9, 2025 for the earlier settlements and December 30, 2025 for the William Raveis, Howard Hanna, EXIT, Windermere, Lyon, Charles Rutenberg, My Home, Tierra Antigua and West USA settlements.
Claim finds settlements you qualify for and helps you file.
Find settlements you qualify for
