Class action guide: your rights in a class action
How to object to a class action settlement
Any class member may object to a proposed class settlement by sending a written objection, in the way and by the date the notice gives, that states whom it applies to and the specific reasons. The court considers objections before deciding whether the settlement is fair, reasonable and adequate. Objecting keeps you in the class, so you can still file a claim.
Key facts
Who can object
Under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 23(e)(5)(A), any class member may object to a proposed settlement that needs court approval. You must still be in the class: in the YouTube privacy settlement (Hubbard v. Google), the FAQ said a person who excludes themselves cannot object, because the settlement no longer affects them, while a class member who objects can still file a claim.
For a class member who is a minor, the YouTube settlement required a parent or legal guardian to submit the objection. Claim's glossary defines an objection.
What an objection must include
Rule 23 requires an objection to state whether it applies only to the objector, to a specific subset of the class, or to the entire class, and to state the grounds for the objection with specificity. Each settlement adds its own requirements in the notice. The YouTube settlement asked for a letter to the court with:
- Your full name, address, telephone number and email address.
- Your lawyer's name and contact details, if you have one.
- Whether the objection applies only to you or to others.
- The reasons you object.
- A statement, declaration or sworn affidavit saying, under penalty of perjury, that you (or the class member) are a member of the settlement class.
- Your signature, and a parent's or guardian's signature for a minor.
YouTube objections had to be mailed to the federal court in San Jose, postmarked no later than December 8, 2025, or filed through the court's electronic filing system by that date. That deadline has passed; follow the address and date in your own notice. The guide what "under penalty of perjury" means explains the declaration.
What the court weighs at final approval
A settlement that would bind class members needs court approval. Under Rule 23(e)(2), the court may approve it only after a hearing and only on finding that it is fair, reasonable and adequate. The rule lists what the court considers, including whether:
- The class representatives and class counsel adequately represented the class.
- The settlement was negotiated at arm's length.
- The relief is adequate, given the costs, risks and delay of trial and appeal, the method of distributing relief and processing claims, and the terms of attorney's fees.
- Class members are treated equitably relative to each other.
The court approves or rejects the settlement as a whole. The YouTube FAQ said a class member cannot ask the court to order a different settlement, and that if the court does not approve it, no settlement payments are made and the lawsuit continues.
Objecting to attorney fees
Fees have their own rule. Under Rule 23(h), the court may award reasonable attorney's fees and nontaxable costs, notice of class counsel's fee motion must be directed to class members, and a class member may object to the motion. In the YouTube settlement, class counsel said they would ask for fees of up to 30% of the $30 million fund, and the FAQ said class members could object to any part of the settlement and to the request for attorneys' fees, costs, expenses and service awards.
Claim's blog explains who pays the lawyers in a class action settlement.
Speaking at the final approval hearing
You do not have to attend the hearing for your objection to count. The YouTube final approval hearing was set for January 13, 2026 by Zoom, and the FAQ said a written objection sent on time would be considered without attending. Class members could also ask to speak; to do so, a class member filed a Notice of Intention to Appear by the deadline.
Claim's glossary explains the final approval hearing and final approval. Claim has a page for the YouTube Kids privacy settlement.
What happens after you object
The YouTube FAQ said that at the hearing the court would consider any objections and could listen to people who had asked to speak. Payments in that settlement were to be made only after final approval and after any appeals were resolved. Rule 23(e)(5)(B) says that, unless the court approves it after a hearing, no payment or other consideration may be given for withdrawing an objection or for dropping an appeal from a judgment approving the settlement.
Appeals can change parts of a settlement. In the Equifax data breach settlement, the Eleventh Circuit Court of Appeals sent the class representative service award issue back to the district court, citing its rulings that prohibit that type of incentive award. The guide the settlement effective date explains when a settlement becomes final.
Settlements on Claim mentioned in this guide
1 result
Frequently asked questions
Can I object and still file a claim?
Yes. The YouTube settlement FAQ said a class member who objects can still file a claim. A person who excludes themselves cannot object.
Do I have to go to the hearing?
No. In the YouTube settlement, a written objection sent on time was considered without attending. To speak at the hearing, a class member had to file a Notice of Intention to Appear.
Can the court change the settlement because of my objection?
The court can approve or reject the settlement; it cannot write a different one. If it rejects the settlement, no settlement payments are made and the case continues.
Can an objector be paid to drop an objection?
Only with court approval after a hearing. Rule 23(e)(5)(B) bars any payment for withdrawing an objection or dropping an appeal unless the court approves it.
Claim finds settlements you qualify for and helps you file.
Find settlements you may qualify for